Production Linked Incentive Schemes: Assessing India’s Manufacturing Transformation

Context

NITI Aayog, in collaboration with the Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad (IIM-A), released a mid-course evaluation report titled Impact Assessment of PLI Schemes, examining the performance of all 14 Production Linked Incentive (PLI) sectors. The assessment evaluates their contribution to investment, manufacturing output, employment generation and export competitiveness, while identifying implementation gaps that need to be addressed.

What is the Mid-Course Assessment of PLI Schemes?

The report provides a comprehensive evaluation of the PLI programme using firm-level data across all 14 notified sectors.

  • Four Assessment Parameters: Examines investment mobilisation, additional production and sales, employment creation and export performance.
  • Outcome-Based Evaluation: Measures the actual contribution of PLI incentives beyond the natural growth trajectory of industries.
  • 50% Performance Benchmark: Uses a mid-course benchmark of 50%, considering that the schemes have completed approximately 58% of their aggregate tenure.
  • Sectoral Classification: Categorises performance into four groups:
    • On-Track
    • Partial Impact
    • Insufficient Evidence
    • Data Unavailable

Key Features of Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Schemes

1. Performance-Linked Financial Support: Incentives are released only after companies demonstrate verified incremental production, sales and prescribed investment, rather than receiving upfront subsidies.

2. Strategic Sectoral Coverage: The programme covers 14 sectors with a cumulative financial outlay of ₹1.91 lakh crore, including electronics, pharmaceuticals, automobiles, textiles, solar PV, advanced chemistry cell batteries and drones.

3. Time-Bound Incentive Structure: Schemes generally operate for five to six years, encouraging manufacturers to expand production, achieve economies of scale and become globally competitive without permanent government support.

4. Differentiated Eligibility Conditions: Investment requirements, incentive rates and Domestic Value Addition (DVA) targets vary across sectors, taking into account differences in technological capabilities and industrial maturity.

5. Integration with Industrial Infrastructure: PLI complements initiatives such as PM GatiShakti, Bulk Drug Parks and PM MITRA Parks to improve logistics, industrial infrastructure and manufacturing ecosystems.

Positive Outcomes of PLI Schemes

1. Strengthening Electronics Manufacturing: Mobile phone production increased approximately 30 times to ₹5.45 lakh crore, while exports expanded nine-fold to nearly ₹2 lakh crore by FY25, enhancing India’s position in global electronics manufacturing.

2. Promoting Pharmaceutical Self-Reliance: The scheme facilitated domestic manufacturing of 191 pharmaceutical products and established 55,000 MT of capacity for 26 critical Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs), helping reduce import dependence and strengthen India’s bulk drug industry.

3. Increasing Domestic Value Addition in Consumer Electronics: Local value addition in air conditioners and LED products increased from approximately 20% to 55%, supported by domestic manufacturing of compressors, printed circuit board assemblies (PCBAs) and other components.

4. Supporting Clean Technology Industries: PLI contributed to approximately 24 GW of integrated solar PV manufacturing capacity and the production of 13.61 lakh electric vehicles. It also supported a seven-fold expansion in drone-sector turnover.

Challenges Associated with PLI Schemes

1. Limited Domestic Value Addition: Despite considerable growth in final product assembly, several sectors continue to depend on imported components and critical raw materials, restricting the development of complete domestic manufacturing ecosystems.

– Example: Mobile phone and telecom manufacturing continues to rely on imported display panels, memory modules, battery cells and bare printed circuit boards.

2. Implementation Delays in Emerging Industries: Capital-intensive sectors face technological limitations, dependence on imported machinery and difficulties in meeting localisation requirements, delaying investment and commercial production.

– Example: Under the ₹18,100 crore Advanced Chemistry Cell (ACC) Battery PLI scheme, only 1.4 GWh of manufacturing capacity was commissioned against the targeted 50 GWh, with no commercial production or incentive disbursement reported in the assessment.

3. Inadequate MSME Participation: High investment thresholds, turnover conditions and compliance requirements have created entry barriers for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), resulting in disproportionate benefits for larger corporations.

– Example: Eligibility restrictions and HSN code-related conditions affected MSME participation in textiles, medical devices and IT Hardware 1.0, requiring subsequent policy modifications.

4. Employment Generation Below Expectations: Although manufacturing investment has increased, job creation remains considerably below the programme’s targets, partly due to automation and delays in project implementation.

– Example: PLI generated approximately 8.49 lakh jobs against a target of 30.18 lakh jobs.

5. Inconsistent Data and Monitoring Mechanisms: Differences in reporting production, exports and employment across ministries make it difficult to distinguish genuinely additional manufacturing activity from existing industrial growth or production reclassification.

Recommendations of NITI Aayog

1. Integrate Demand-Side and Supply-Side Measures: Combine production incentives with government procurement, downstream demand creation and export promotion to ensure that increased manufacturing capacity translates into sustainable market demand.

2. Establish Standardised Data Reporting: Develop uniform indicators across ministries for measuring production, physical output, domestic value addition, net exports and employment. Automated verification and periodic monitoring can improve accountability.

3. Introduce Sector-Specific Policy Frameworks: Set investment thresholds, localisation requirements and implementation timelines after consulting industry stakeholders and considering technological complexity and sectoral maturity.

4. Strengthen Domestic Supply Chains: Promote indigenous component manufacturing, research and development and domestic sourcing of critical raw materials to reduce import dependence and deepen value addition.

5. Expand MSME Participation: Improve access to finance, simplify compliance requirements and integrate smaller enterprises into the supply chains of large manufacturing companies.

6. Improve Centre–State Coordination: Establish effective institutional mechanisms to address land acquisition, labour availability, infrastructure constraints and regulatory delays, particularly in capital-intensive sectors.

7. Strengthen Outcome-Based Evaluation: Introduce transparent monitoring systems and realistic performance indicators to assess additional investment, production, exports and employment throughout the scheme’s implementation period.

Conclusion

The mid-course assessment demonstrates that PLI schemes have contributed significantly to India’s manufacturing expansion, particularly in electronics and pharmaceuticals. However, increased production alone cannot guarantee long-term industrial competitiveness. Moving towards Viksit Bharat @2047 requires deeper domestic value addition, stronger MSME participation, employment-oriented manufacturing, resilient supply chains and sustained demand creation. A shift from incentivising production volumes to building globally competitive manufacturing ecosystems will be essential for achieving durable industrial self-reliance.

Source : PIB

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top