Cloud Seeding in Delhi: Science, Applications, and Challenges

Context
- Recently, the Government of the National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi conducted cloud seeding operations to induce artificial rain as an emergency measure to reduce air pollution.
- This initiative has sparked interest in understanding the science behind cloud seeding, its applications, limitations, and its effectiveness as a temporary intervention for environmental challenges.
1. What is Cloud Seeding?
- Definition: Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique aimed at enhancing precipitation by dispersing chemical agents into existing clouds.
- Mechanism:
- Chemicals act as artificial condensation nuclei, promoting the formation of larger water droplets or ice crystals, which eventually leads to rainfall.
- Seeding Agents:
- Silver iodide – Mimics ice crystal structures.
- Potassium iodide – Alternative nucleating agent.
- Dry ice (solid CO₂) – Rapidly cools the air.
- Sodium chloride (common salt) – Promotes droplet formation in warm clouds.
- Dispersal Methods:
- Aircraft dispersal.
- Ground-based generators when wind conditions allow aerosol transport.
- Drones for targeted seeding operations.
2. Key Requirements for Artificial Rain
Scientific Preconditions:
- Moisture-rich clouds – Only existing clouds like cumulus and nimbostratus can be seeded; clear skies cannot generate rain.
- Sufficient moisture content – Cloud must contain at least 50% water content.
- Cloud characteristics:
- Vertical thickness of at least 1 km.
- Cold cloud seeding: requires “supercooled” droplets at −20°C to −7°C.
- Warm cloud seeding: requires temperatures above freezing.
- Favourable wind conditions:
- Wind must transport seeding material to the target area.
- Speed should allow clouds to grow vertically without dispersing agents.
- Vertical air currents: Strong updrafts help disperse agents and promote rainfall.
3. Monsoon Relevance and Limitations
Relevance:
- The Indian monsoon provides abundant moisture and widespread clouds, ideal for targeting rain-deficient areas.
Limitations:
- Natural rainfall can obscure the impact of cloud seeding.
- Atmospheric variability may reduce effectiveness.
- Risk of excessive rainfall or local flooding if not managed properly.
4. Applications of Cloud Seeding
- Temporary relief: Mitigates severe droughts and supports agriculture and rural water security.
- Air quality intervention: Artificial rain helps wash pollutants from the air, especially in cities like Delhi.
- Agricultural stabilization: Supplements rainfall during delayed or weak monsoons.
5. Limitations and Challenges
- Environmental risks: Chemical agents may contaminate soil and water, affecting biodiversity and soil fertility.
- Limited effectiveness: Cannot induce rain without suitable clouds or moisture.
- Ethical/legal concerns: Manipulating rainfall can affect neighboring regions, raising geopolitical and ethical issues.
- Region-specific challenges (Delhi/Indo-Gangetic Plains):
- Winter pollution occurs under low humidity, limiting efficacy.
- Cloud seeding provides short-lived rainfall, lasting a few hours to a couple of days.
6. Status of Cloud Seeding in India
- Historical Use: India has experimented with cloud seeding since the 1950s, initially for drought management.
- State-level Initiatives: Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh have conducted operations in water-scarce regions.
- Delhi’s Revival (2025):
- MoU with IIT Kanpur for five cloud-seeding trials in northwest Delhi.
- Approved by 23 departments, including DGCA, aiming to tackle winter pollution.
- IIT Kanpur will deploy own aircraft for the operations.
7. Recommendations
- Scientific validation: Use satellite data, Doppler radar, and high-resolution meteorological models.
- Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs): Develop protocols for execution, monitoring, and post-event assessment.
- Regulatory framework: Ensure environmental safety, ethical governance, and transparency.
- Long-term solutions: Cloud seeding should remain a supplementary intervention, not a primary pollution-control strategy.
- Comprehensive analysis: Decisions should be based on meteorological assessments, transparent processes, and risk evaluation.
Conclusion
- Short-term: Cloud seeding can serve as an emergency measure during extreme air pollution or droughts.
- Long-term: India must focus on sustainable air-quality solutions, climate-resilient urban planning, and environmental management.
- While scientifically plausible, cloud seeding is highly conditional and must be integrated into a broader, multi-layered environmental strategy rather than relied upon as a permanent solution.
Source : The Hindu